Wednesday, May 25, 2011

Stop Picking on my Baby

"Ewww! You smell gross! Stop doing such yucky, stinky poos!!"


Today I asked someone to stop picking on my child. "How would you feel if you were sneered at and hassled because you had done a poo in your clothes, and you couldn't help it?"

Somewhere along the way people seem to have forgotten that when they are talking to a pre-verbal child, they are talking to a person. My 16-month-old child is not oblivious to derision. He understands when someone wrinkles up their nose in sneers of disgust, and he is powerless to do anything about it. But I'm not.

If there's one thing that has influenced my choice of preferred authors on parenting, it's my preconception that babies are people too. Authors such as Barbara Coloroso, Louise Porter, Alfie Kohn, Thomas Gordon... they are all quick to point out that relationships we form with our children are the real persuasive power that we have in their lives. They want to do as those around them do, and the only way they are going to learn how to treat others is by our example.

I once heard, anecdotally, that Japanese parents treat their baby as though they are a guest. Whether this is true or not is neither here nor there, but I liked the idea. A guest is assumed to be ignorant of local custom, is provided for, and is gently instructed how best to get on with others. They are treated with respect. Somewhere along the way someone forgot to pass this memo on to parents who talk over their children's heads, or say mean things to their little ones assuming that the child doesn't know what it means. Just because your baby can't speak doesn't mean they can't comprehend what you are saying, or what your body language is conveying.

Okay, so nobody is going to say it's bad parenting to pick up a child and say "you smell bad, darling... time for a change"... then again, if they are anti-nappies/diapers they might, but I digress... my point is that some parents and family members are not sharing a joke with their kids, they are making a joke at the child's expense. They seem to have forgotten one of the cardinal rules of play;
"It's not a good game unless everyone is enjoying it."


We teach this to 4-year-olds but somewhere along the way some people fail to engage empathy when dealing with kids. They lie to children to play tricks on them, they mock them in front of others, they laugh at them for not knowing or not being able to do things that they have no experience at. In schools this is called bullying, but it's the normal way to parent in many families.

A boy I once knew, aged about 7, was brought by his father to meet up with some people. They were all going to have PIZZA! He was overjoyed at being invited along to such a special dinner, and with his father's friends too! He walked in the door and was told "Sorry. You have to go home. You are too late. We already had the pizza without you." I remember the look of shock, disappointment, confusion and hurt in a child's face when others said "no no no....". He was feeling completely lost in an adult social situation with grown ups laughing at him ("you should have seen his face!! *haw haw haw*).

I have been criticised for being thin skinned. I don't like to use sarcasm or mean humour because I find it distasteful. I know that some parents jibe their children because they see it as important life learning. They think it is important for children to learn that this sort of thing is inconsequential. Learn to get over yourself. Man up. I'm okay with parents making decisions like this consciously, but in my perfect world, carers for our next generation ought to be reflective and thoughtful about the decisions they make, and too many people bully their kids not because they are making a mindful choice, but because they can, and it makes them feel powerful.

For now, the goal that I have decided on is that I will be truthful with my children. I will be kind and empathic with my children. I will be reliable and I will be fair and I will not beat them down with words. I will not always succeed in this. Everyone gets tired, or angry, or exasperated at times, but our aspirations are what keeps us improving, and in those quiet moments? My children are not "icky"... they just need my care.

4 comments:

Max said...

Beautifully written and I couldn't agree with it more. What gets to me most when I notice parents who laugh because they find their child crying funny. It makes me feel quite physically sick, the lack of empathy and its so common.

Kath Rushworth said...

I have issues with parents who deliberately scare their children over and over again by jumping out at them from doorways in the night, threatening to drop them, or threatening to leave them behind when they are going home. From personal experience, kids like that often play mean pranks on their "friends" and family members and basically just learn that it's appropriate to be mean spirited and make others feel small.

Eddie & Jo said...

Also am in complete agreement. I commend you on your parenting *style* for lack of a better word. As an as yet fairly neutral, cultural entity I think toddlers need to be treated so carefully in terms of what they are exposed to, treated as and what they over-hear. I'm just winging it & have not read-up as you have (*guilt*) but I also know first hand that the consequences can be larger than we care to think about at the time. I love the idea of treating your kid as some kind of guest (politeness/ respect) but with house rules.

Kath Rushworth said...

Thanks :)

Further to a comment made on Facebook:
I guess it's all about creating a culture of trust. Some parents think that if they don't lie to their kids the kids will be in control, or that if they don't spin a line their kids will grow up gullible with no "bull-shit-o-meter" as it were.

My personal position on this is that family should be the inner sanctum. They are the ones with whom you learn to trust and this gives you the ability to have healthy, loving relationships in later life.

Eddie&Jo
I think that winging it is great so long as you are thinking about it and listening to your instincts on it. I sacrifice time with my kids for "professional development" (research, reading books etc.). It takes me a while to read books about this sort of thing and I have to assess whether it's worth my time or not, but I figure if I enjoy it, I am helping spread the information along to others, and it's making me a better informed parent then it's all worth it :)